How Long Will Your Digital Prints Last?
You May Be Surprised Page 2
Light Fade
For most types of digital photo prints light fade is the dominant factor to
consider when predicting display permanence (an exception is dye-based ink jet
prints made on instant-dry photo papers). To accelerate light fade, scientists
construct very bright chambers that maintain a temperature and relative humidity
similar to a typical home. Photographers who want to be confident about light
fade predictions based on the Wilhelm standard should be aware of several points:
First, the Wilhelm calculation assumes a brightly lit indoor room--450
lux average for 12 hours per day. The published Kodak method assumes a less
brightly lit room--120 lux/12 hours per day. Thus, the Kodak method will
predict more years of lightfastness than the Wilhelm method.
Second, the Wilhelm standard also uses a stringent definition of failure--the
tests are conducted until just a noticeable amount of fading has occurred, and
17 failure criteria are tracked.
Finally, as a reality check, long-term (>1 year) "slow fade"
rate studies are conducted in light chambers that are only 2-10 times brighter
than the nominal real-world condition.
Room-Temperature Thermal Degradation Or "Dark Fade"
This factor is the relatively slow thermal degradation of colorants and paper
that occurs even at room temperature. Historically called "dark fade"
because traditional silver-halide photos could change significantly even when
stored in the dark, this factor also applies to displayed photos. The accelerated
test requires long-term tests of more than a year at several elevated temperatures
(e.g., 55ÞC-70ÞC). The results are then extrapolated to a room temperature
(e.g., 25ÞC) prediction.
Fortunately, ink jet colorants (dye and pigment) are very stable and typically
can last 100+ years at room temperature, so dark fade is usually not a limiting
permanence factor for ink jet photo prints as long as high-quality paper is
used. Thermal degradation was historically a significant issue for traditional
color silver-halide photos due to residual chemicals from the development process.
Wilhelm-Research.com has published a variety of thermal degradation data for
ink jet and silver-halide photos. Dye sublimation photos cannot withstand the
elevated temperatures required by the accelerated test, so long-term longevity
is unknown at this time for dye sublimation prints.
Air Fade Or "Ozone Fade"
Ink jet photos made with dye-based inks on highly porous (e.g., "instant
dry") photo papers can experience noticeable air fade within months of
exposure. Many customer complaints about premature fading of ink jet prints
were actually due to air fade on these highly porous papers; light fade may
have been a minor contributor. These complaints could have been prevented by
avoiding instant-dry photo papers and choosing encapsulating papers instead,
or by protecting the prints with glass or lamination.
Air fade of an ink jet photo print is caused by direct contact with airborne
gases and pollutants, primarily ozone. Accelerated tests use exposure to a high
level (> 1 ppm) of ozone until noticeable fading occurs. Next, the months
(or years) of ozone fade resistance is calculated based on indoor data averages
(e.g., 40 ppm-hours of ozone equivalent to one year "real world").
Manufacturers' claims for air fade are currently not based on a common
method; fortunately, Wilhelm-Research.com is now collecting ozone fade data
to enable product comparisons.
Silver-halide photos have a protective layer that can greatly reduce air fade.
Ink jet photos made on papers with
self-encapsulating "swellable" layers (e.g., HP Premium Plus Photo
Paper), or ink jet photos made with pigmented inks, in general are quite resistant
to air/ozone fade and should last decades even if displayed without a protective
cover. According to Wilhelm-Research.com, dye sublimation ozone resistance ranges
from approximately one decade to many.
Humidity Fastness
Significant exposure to relative humidity higher than about 80 percent can cause
colorants to migrate, thereby causing color changes or loss of sharpness. Long
exposure to very high humidity can cause microbial growth and discoloration.
Test labs can expose prints to elevated humidity for a period of weeks to qualitatively
rank the relative humidity fastness of different products based on measured
color changes. As with light fade, humidity fastness is typically improved by
using the manufacturer's branded paper that is matched to that particular
brand of ink.
How Long Will My Photo Last?
The answer to this question depends on what type--and brand--of print
technology are used, and whether the photo is displayed or stored (see table
below).
Print Technology | Display Permanence (Glass Protected) |
Air Fade Resistance | Storage Permanence |
Digital Silver Halide | 17-40 years, dependingon brand | Decades | 100+ years w/quality processing |
Ink Jet | 100+ years for some branded ink/papers; but less than 5 years for other combinations | Decades (pigments, or dyes + encapsulating paper); months (most dyes + porous paper) |
100+ years, premium brands (200+ years some brands) |
Dye Sublimation | 4-8 years lightfastness (one brand: 26 years) | Decades (most brands) | Currently unknown |
Regardless of which digital printing technology you select, it is always a good practice to display photos behind glass for protection and to avoid display locations with direct sunlight, excessive humidity, or high temperature. Don't rely just on manufacturers' claims, but consult independent test lab results.
- Log in or register to post comments