Using Invisible Filters
Kicking Your Images Up A Notch

Joe Farace, July, 2000

This photographic sequence of model Adele Newton was made on Kodak E100 VS slide film using only light from a north facing window supplemented with a 30” F.J. Westcott Illuminator “Sunlight” reflector. She was photographed with seven different Tiffen Hollywood/FX diffusion filters, but you will find that there is no “perfect” diffusion filter when photographing people. While the warm toned filters worked better for a fair-skinned model like Ms. Newton, you need to evaluate your own subjects and filter accordingly. No Filter. Photos © Joe Farace, 2000 What would it be like to be invisible? --H.G. Wells’ “The Invisible Man” Unlike the character from H.G. Wells’ novel or James Whale’s classic 1933 horror movie, you can actually see these filters. I use the term as a way to differentiate them from the filters used for black and white, special effects, or infrared photography. One of the biggest advantages of shooting with invisible filters is that your final image doesn’t shout filter; instead they often look as if the photographs were made without using any kind of filter at all. This article takes a look at several types that I consider to be “invisible” along with a few suggestions on how to use them to improve your photographs, and have some fun at the same time. The invisible filters mentioned in this article are available from Adorama, B+W, Cokin, Heliopan, Hoya, Lee, Sunpak, Tiffen, and other manufacturers. While many camera companies also make them, the focus here is on filters that are designed to fit many different brands of 35mm cameras.

Warm Soft/FX 1. They Almost Look Invisible. Of all the categories of filters--invisible or not--one of the more controversial and sure to start an argument among photographers, is the use of filters as lens protection. Many photographers use Skylight or UV (Ultra Violet) filters for that purpose and there’s a class of filters, called “P” or “Clear” that offer nothing but protection for the front element of your lenses. To some photographic purists the idea of placing any kind of filter, even ones made from fine quality optical glass, in front of their lenses is offensive. In the not so distant past, I must confess to mounting a Skylight (my preferred protection filter) on every lens I owned. These days, I’ve mellowed a bit on this practice and only attach them when working under less hospitable situations, such as at the beach or in the desert. When shooting indoors or under other conditions, my Skylight filters come off. That’s not to say that skylight and UV filters don’t have their places.

Warm Soft/FX 2. In addition to protecting the front element of your lens, a Skylight, also called “1-A”, “Sky 1-A” or “KR,” filter can absorb UV light and provide a slight warming effect for films that tend to represent colors on the cool side. It can absorb 46 percent of the UV light in a scene, while a dedicated UV filter will subtract 71 percent. Stronger UV filters, such as Tiffen’s Haze 2A, absorb almost all UV light. For photographers who find themselves working in high altitude locations, such as the Rocky Mountains, a UV filter can be a big help with the high UV conditions they’ll encounter.

Black Pro-Mist 1. Polarizers. A polarizing filter eliminates reflections from non-metallic surfaces, increases color saturation, and can enhance an image’s overall contrast. It’s easy to abuse them by creating overpolarized post card like views or landscapes, but the judicious use of the polarizer can also add punch to your images. Many modular filters, such as those from Cokin and Lee, are made of optical plastic. When used with a polarizer, you should not position them between the polarizer and the subject. Instead, place them between the lens and polarizer. It used to be easy to purchase a polarizer: You went into a camera store, asked for one that matched your lens’ filter thread size and you were ready to go. Nowadays, depending on your camera design, you may have to decide between a circular or linear polarizer. I used to think only autofocus cameras required one, but HP Marketing reminded me that Canon’s FT was the first camera requiring a circular polarizer and it wasn’t an autofocus model.

Black Pro-Mist 2. The true qualifier for requiring a circular polarizer is whether or not your camera uses a semi-silvered mirror or beam splitter for metering or autofocus. When I switched to the Contax 35mm system, I wondered which one I would need for my cameras. Contax told me it depended on the camera model: when using the built-in spot metering capabilities, the Contax Aria, ST, RTS III, and 167MT models require a circular polarizer. In other metering modes, a linear polarizer works fine. The Contax AX and RX models, on the other hand, require a circular polarizer to operate properly with their focusing systems. As you can see, the kind of polarizer you need may not be as obvious as you might think. To find out, read your camera owner’s manual or visit one of the web sites listed. If you cannot find out for certain it is always safe to use a circular polarizer since they will never interfere with any camera function.

Black Pro-Mist 3. These days, there seems to be an indefinite number of spins that can be put on polarizers. Many manufacturers offer warm polarizers that combine a polarizer with a warming filter. Hoya offers a circular polarizer made from UV filtering glass to provide the effects of UV filtration and polarization at the same time, while Heliopan has a complete series including circular, linear and warm tone Käsemann polarizers with special edge sealing for working in extreme climates. Neutral Density. If there is one that could be called the Rodney Dangerfield of photography it’s the Neutral Density (ND) filter. It lets you achieve control over an image when a combination of film speed, lens aperture, and shutter speeds won’t let you produce the effect you want. For example, if you want to slow your shutter speed to produce smooth flowing water and your lens is already at its smallest aperture, an ND filter will let you drop down as much as three more shutter speeds. Conversely, if you would prefer to use a wider lens aperture to blur the background for a portrait, but have the camera set at its highest shutter speed and the aperture is still too small, an ND filter lets you open up a few stops.

Warm Black Pro-Mist 2. They are available in different shades of gray and are typically rated by how many f/stops they decrease your lens settings. For example a light gray ND filter produces a one-stop decrease, a medium gray gives a two stop decrease, and a dark gray usually provides a three stop decrease. Most companies make filters in these three categories, but B+W and Hoya produce them in heavier densities for special, industrial, or scientific applications. Heliopan even offers a double polarizer that’s really two filters sandwiched together that can be rotated 90° to create stepless variable neutral density. Many are available in thin mounts, making them easier to use on extreme wide angle lenses. Because filter companies often use proprietary designations to differentiate their neutral density filters, you can easily get confused about which one to use. The chart accompanying this article shows the company’s name and number of f/stops that the filter will absorb.

Warm Black Pro-Mist 3. Graduated Neutral Density. These filters have a clear area at the bottom and somewhere around the middle, blending into an area of gradually darkening gray. They allow you to control areas of excessive brightness, such as a sky, bringing them into balance with the rest of a scene. The darker area covers less than half of the filter, but the effect can be adjusted vertically by moving square or rectangular modular filters up and down in their holders. Round graduated neutral density filters, such as Tiffen’s Color Grad ND 6, rotate much like a polarizer. The effect on the photograph will vary based on the distance that the filter is placed in front of the lens, the position of a (modular) filter in its holder, the focal length of the lens, and the density of the filter used. The effect is more pronounced when a wide angle lens is used at small apertures, with an opposite effect produced at wider apertures with longer lenses.

This photographic sequence looks straight out of Middle America but was actually made in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains. The images were made on Kodak E100 VS slide film with a Contax 167MT and 50mm f/1.4 lens. The classic way to “punch up” skies is with a polarizing filter but the point of maximum polarization is 90° from the sun. In between there is less. That’s when you might try a graduated ND filter to add effects that can range from subtle to brooding. No Filter. When looking through graduated neutral density filters, you can easily see the place where it changes from clear to neutral density. When it’s attached to your camera it’s not always so obvious where to position the filter in order to achieve the expected results. Here’s what you should do: before inserting or screwing on the filter, take a light meter or manual reading of the foreground area. After attaching the filter, use your camera’s depth of field preview control to stop the lens down to the shooting aperture. When looking through the lens you’ll be able to clearly see where the density shift is on your image. This is also the time to experiment and move the filter up or down in order to position the gradation effect exactly where you want it. As you move the filter, the effect of the gradation will become readily apparent. Most graduated neutral density filters are available in different strengths. Singh-Ray’s filters, which are compatible with Cokin’s “P” holder, are available in two “soft-step” and two “hard-step” models. The soft-step models are designed for scenes with no distinct boundary between the light and dark areas. The hard-step models work best in scenes where sky and foreground are distinctly separated at the horizon. Both are offered in two or three-step density gradations. Cokin’s two Grey Graduated filters pass the “duck test.” They look, walk, and “quack” like graduated ND filters, but the company calls them “Grey.”

Cokin Polarizer Filter. Let’s Get Real Soft. Photographers love to purchase the sharpest lenses they can afford, but the first filter many of them use produces some form of diffusion to soften that image. Soft focus or diffusion filters can be used to soften a landscape without suppressing detail or to hide minor flaws on a portrait subject’s skin. Diffusion filters come in an amazing variety, starting with “soft focus” up to “fog.” The classic Zeiss Softar is available in three strengths, with one being the least soft and three being the softest. When looking at portraits made with a Softar I, the effect is not readily apparent until you compare it with an unfiltered image, which is when the true value of this invisible filter will be immediately apparent. These expensive filters are available in various sizes from Heliopan and Contax as well as in medium format bayonet sizes from Hasselblad and Rollei.

Cokin 120 (light) Gray Graduated Filter. One of my favorite group of soft focus filters is Tiffen’s Hollywood/FX series. It includes a diverse group of products call Pro-Mist that are available in variations such as Warm Black, Black, and Warm Soft. As I was finishing this article, Tiffen introduced two new diffusion filters for movie and TV use. The Black Diffusion/FX filter adds a smooth look to textured surfaces, such as facial imperfections, and the Gold Diffusion/FX filters create a softening effect while adding a golden tone to shadows. When comparing a Soft FX No. 5 to a BDFX, the Soft FX appears more “dreamlike,” whereas the Black Diffusion/FX is simply softer. The GDFX keeps skin tones and neutral colors compared to the warmer effects produced by a Warm Soft FX filter. Under certain lighting conditions, BDFX filters produce more subtle softening than the, Soft FX and don’t create halation, tending instead to tone down highlights. Currently, they are only available in 4x4 and Panavision sizes for movie and TV use, but the company is considering introducing the BDFX in selected screw-in sizes in a kit that would include No. 3 and No. 5 filters. If and when a BDFX kit is available, I’ll let you know.

Filters are available in the classic round glass screw-on type as well as modular types, like these Lee filters, that are designed to fit a wide variety of lenses. The next big step past diffusion is “Fog.” One of the more interesting takes on fog filters is Lee Filters’ Mist set. It consists of a graduated Mist, Mist Stripe and Mist Centre Spot filters, any of which can be used individually or in combination to create varying densities of mist and fog. Lee filters measure 100x150mm and are designed to fit one of the company’s filter holders or bellows lens shades. As with many kinds of “invisible” filters, you may have to switch your camera into manual focus mode to make sure you get the maximum sharpness from your soft image. Wrapping Up. No single article can cover all of the various technical elements about how filters work or even the best way to use them. I’ve tried to introduce you to what I feel is a special class of filters and included several reasons why they should be part of your basic photographic tool kit. While looking through a manufacturer’s filter catalog you may discover that there are a few others that might fall into the “invisible” category but haven’t been covered here. Even though they exhibit some subtle color, Enhancer filters might be one of the most notable examples. At this year’s PMA show, many companies wanted to build on the popularity of the red Enhancer to carve out a niche for new kinds of filters, including green and blue Enhancer or Intensifiers. A look at these products will be saved for a future foray into the world of filters. Camera Filters On The Web Using filters may seem a long way from using a computer, but there’s lots of good information about filters and their technology available on the World Wide Web. Here’s a guide to locating web sites that can help you learn more about using filters--both invisible and visible. B+W filters: www.schneideroptics.com/filters/filters.htm Cokin filters: www.cokin.co.uk The Filter Connection: www.2filter.com/ Heliopan filters: www.hpmarketingcorp.com Hoya filters: www.thkphoto.com Lee filters: www.leefilters.com Lindahl Specialties: www.lslindahl.com Pro-Optic: www.adoramacamera.com Singh-Ray filters: www.singhray.com Sunpak filters: www.tocad.com Tiffen filters: www.tiffen.com

f/Stop Loss B+W Cokin Heliopan Hoya Lee ProOptic from Adorama Sunpak Tiffen 1 101 Gray ND2X ND 0,3 NDX2 0.3 ND 152 nd2x ND3 2 1102 Gray ND4X ND 0,6 NDX4 0.6 ND 155 nd4x ND6 3 103   ND 0,9 NDX8 0.9 ND   nd3x ND9 6 106               9       ND400         10 110               13 113               20 120               Manufacturers/Distributors Adorama, Inc. (Pro-Optic filters) 42 W 18th St. New York, NY 10011 (800) 223-2500 (212) 675-6789 fax: (212) 463-7223 HP Marketing Corp. (Heliopan Filters) 16 Chapin Rd. Pine Brook, NJ 07058 (800) 735-4373 Kyocera Corporation Yashica/Contax Optical Division 2301-200 Cottontail Lane Somerset, NJ 08873 (800) 526-0266 www.yashica.com Lee Filters 2237 N Hollywood Way Burbank, CA 91505 (818) 238-1220 fax: (818) 238-1228 Lindahl Specialties 800 W Beardsley Ave. PO Box 1365 Elkhart, IN 46514 (219) 296-7823 fax: (219) 296-7636 Minolta Corporation (Cokin Filters) 101 Williams Dr. Ramsey, NJ 07446 (201) 825-4000 Omega/Satter 1041 S Carroll St. Hampstead, MD 21074 (410) 374-3250 www.Omega.Satter.com Pro4 Imaging Inc. 21 Spragg Cir. Markham, Ontario Canada, L3P 5W1 (905) 294-3041 fax: (905) 294-4611 www.pro4.com Sailwind Photo/Camera World 1809 Commonwealth Ave. Charlotte, NC 28205 (704) 375-8453 fax: (704) 376-1826 Schneider Optics (B+W filters) 285 Oser Ave. Hauppauge, NY 11788 (631) 761-5000 fax: 631-761-5090 Singh-Ray Filters 2721 SE Highway 31 Arcadia FL 34266 (800) 486-5501 fax: (863) 993-4100 THK Photo Products, Inc. (Hoya filters) 2360 Mira Mar Ave. Long Beach, CA 90815 (562) 494-9575 (800) 421-1141 fax: (562) 494-3375 Tiffen Manufacturing Corp. 90 Oser Ave. Hauppauge, NY 11788 (516) 273-2500 fax: (516) 273-2557 ToCAD America, Inc. (Sunpak filters) 300 Webro Rd. Parsippany, NJ 07504 (973) 428-9800 F.J. Westcott Co. 1447 Summit St. Toledo, OH 43604 (419) 243-7311 fax: (419) 243-840